Your browser does not support JavaScript


The Shrinking Social Security Benefit (from Kiplinger's Retirement Report)
Wednesday, July 22, 2020

Catherine Siskos - Kiplinger's Retirement Report

The pandemic that shuttered businesses and left 40 million Americans unemployed also means fewer dollars flowing into Social Security's coffers. What does the pandemic economy bode for people already collecting benefits or who hope to do so one day?

The good news is that Social Security can pay 100% of benefits for the next dozen or so years and about 75% of benefits thereafter, even if 1 in 5 people are unemployed for the next 24 months, according to the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.

The bad news is that changes baked into the program are coming home to roost, and the effect is that benefits keep getting stingier. "Once we get through this pandemic, the attention should be on fixing the program," says CRR's director Alicia H. Munnell.

Fixing Social Security isn't insurmountable. Hiking payroll taxes 1.6% for employers and employees would fully fund the program for the next 75 years, according to a CRR report. Social Security is already tapping interest from the program's trust fund to pay benefits and will begin dipping into fund assets next year, the first time that's happened since 1982. Left alone, the fund could be depleted by 2033, two years sooner than originally projected because of the pandemic economy.

After that, the program would rely entirely on annual payroll tax revenue. At first, retirees would get 79 cents for every dollar they'd earned in benefits, dropping to 73 cents per dollar by the end of the century. No one, of course, expects that to happen. "Politically, it's untenable," says Nancy Altman, president of Social Security Works, a nonprofit advocacy group.

But even if Congress fixes Social Security's funding, benefits are still shrinking. In fact, they have been for some time because of the rising retirement age. In 1983, Congress gradually raised the full retirement age for people born between 1938 and 1960. Because of the way Social Security's actuarial formula is calculated, the replacement rate - the amount of money a beneficiary receives compared to preretirement earnings - fell as the retirement age rose, with the steepest cuts hitting those born in 1960 or later.

Social Security's benefits table bears this out. The full retirement age for someone born in 1937 is 65. A monthly benefit of $1,000 drops to $800 if that individual retires early at 62, which makes sense given that benefits accrue the longer you wait to take them.

But someone born a year later in 1938, who would have received $1,000 at the full retirement age of 65 and two months, gets just $791 per month at age 62. The benefit amount continues to drop with those born in 1960 or later getting just $700 at age 62 of the $1,000 benefit they would have received at the full retirement age of 67. "Raising the retirement age is cutting benefits," says Munnell. As long as Congress keeps the full retirement age at 67, the replacement rate will level off in 2022 and benefits should stop shrinking.

Unfortunately, the same can't be said for their purchasing power, which continues to fall. Social Security's annual cost of living adjustments can't keep up with health care costs, which have been rising faster than other goods and services, translating into a 30% loss of buying power for benefits since 2000, according to a Senior Citizens League study. Seniors spend more than twice as much on health care as younger adults.

Benefits are also staying frozen more often. Since COLAs began in 1975, only three years - 2010, 2011 and 2016 - had no increases, but all occurred in the past decade. The pandemic's weak economy and crashing oil prices mean no COLAs are expected for 2020.

If there's a bright side, says Kurt Czarnowski of Cznarowski Consulting, a Social Security and retirement planning firm, it's this: "There's no provision for taking money away from beneficiaries," in years when the cost of living doesn't increase.

Read full article here.

Subscribe To Our Blog

Blog Categories

  • General
    • 10/13/2020 - Situational Social Security –
    • 10/05/2020 - Social Security Retirement Ben
    • 10/03/2020 - Situational Social Security (S
    • 07/22/2020 - The Shrinking Social Security
    • 07/14/2020 - Advisor Virtual Resilience Ser
    • 06/22/2020 - NSSA, the nation's only accred
    • 06/10/2020 - National Social Security Advis
    • 04/22/2020 - National Social Security Advis
    • 10/23/2019 - Premier Social Security Consul
    • 09/11/2019 - Jim Blair helps to shed light
    • 07/15/2019 - Premier Social Security Consul
    • 09/20/2018 - NAIFA Conference Highlights th
    • 10/14/2016 - Baby Boomer Market
    • 11/28/2015 - Social Strategies
    • 11/28/2015 - Budget Bill Changes
    • 11/25/2015 - New Social Security Claiming S
    • 08/26/2015 - Expert Discussion with NSSA An
    • 08/26/2015 - NSSA Exhibits Missouri Society
    • 08/26/2015 - Financially Stable Retirement
Get news from Premier Social Security Consulting in your inbox. SIGN UP FOR UPDATES


You guys helped close a big case with that answer really appreciate it. Thank you for the great work you both do.
Patrick C, California
I attended your class and passed the NSSA assessment 2 1/2 years ago. The NSSA Certificate been a career boost and my clientele is reflecting that.
Kimberly H, Ohio
Thanks for providing such valuable information and updates on a periodic basis. It really helps with conversations that I have with my clients.  Excellent support.
Rayyan A
I am very pleased that I came to the education . .  What I learned is what I came for and to know that the video will be available for backup is great.
Bob Z
You guys rock!  I am thoroughly enjoying your SS online course!
David T, Florida
I am enjoying the course and love the conversation between you guys on the videos, especially the trials and tribulations of party animal "Harold."
Chris K, Connecticut
Social Security is complex program where the choice you make can mean thousands of dollars of extra earnings in retirement. Knowing these choices is important to my clients and NSSA [Certificate program] has increased my ability to guide them in the right direction.
James B
Just want to say it's really great having you two to lean on when I'm uncertain.  You've trained me well but sometimes question myself.  Thanks for doing what you do!
Barbara S, Colorado
Thank you and Jim for the incredible work and effort put into these webinars, videos etc, let alone this program. Really a blessing to have been directed to you. Karl W was absolutely right: you guys are class acts.
Alan K
Thanks guys, it is VERY much appreciated to have you take time out of your day to answer a complicated question from time to time that comes across our desks.
Bradley W, California
Thanks for the SS training last week! Learned a lot and looking forward to further focus on this important part of the financial planning matrix!
Leslie C, Kentucky
I really appreciate your examples, they make it come alive more so than articles describing strategies.
Over the last 12 months since earning the NSSA Certificate I have brought in 40 additional clients and $400,000 in additional revenues.
David S, Washington State
I appreciate that you are always there to support me. It means a lot! 
Danielle A, Kansas
I finished the on demand class today . .  I really enjoyed the class and I learned a lot. 
Adam H, Illinois
NSSA has directly increased my credibility, my business, and overall client experience and satisfaction.
Kimberly Y, Ohio
I thought the information was outstanding!  I was anxious to get started and improve my foundation of knowledge surrounding social security as it has become a significant portion of our planning.
David G, Florida
This course has been very helpful to clients already, thanks again, Sam
Sam D, Connecticut
It was so nice talking with you yesterday.  I was super impressed how quickly you called me!
Susan C, Florida
Thanks again for the training you provided it has been invaluable for my practice.
Stacey A, TN
Thanks again for the great training. I started using the information I learned with my clients immediately. It has really added to my credibility!
Rich M, Texas
I hope all is well my friend. We filled up another 100 people last month and taught them all about social security, this is truly something special we have created to help out thousands of San Diegans and counting.
Brad W, California



Follow us on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter
Follow us on LinkedIn
NSSA Discussions


Premier Social Security Consulting, LLC
7361 East Kemper Road Unit B
Cincinnati, Ohio 45249

513-218-8505 (Cell)
ICE 1100 Accredited Certificate Program
Situational Social Security Checklist
Gain access to questions that help you understand your client’s situation for only $50.